The instrumental data we explored above gives a small window of time in Earth’s recent history. To put the recent changes into context, we need to also consider long term changes in sea level.
Humans typically have difficulty thinking about time beyond a human lifespan. Geologists may be the exception to this rule, but you may belong in the category of those who find it difficult to visualize the long distant past and the long distant future and to think in terms of millions or billions of years (or even thousands of years). But understanding the changes to atmospheric and ocean changes in the geologic history of the Earth is important if we are to understand what is going on with our climate and sea levels today.
Thinking REALLY long term: Below is a graph plotting sea level over the past 540 million years - since the Cambrian era. For reference, zero on the Y-axis is where the current sea level is. We don’t need to go into a lot of detail, but you can easily appreciate that sea levels have been much higher than today for much of this period of the Earth's history. Scientists have correlated these fluctuations with changes in atmospheric carbon dioxide and ocean and atmospheric temperatures, using methods described in the next few pages.
We also must acknowledge here that some people may argue that sea levels have always fluctuated, so why is sea level rise today a big deal? Hopefully, we can shed some light on this question by looking at the changes in sea level through the history of the Earth, while considering the causes for these changes. But, perhaps the simple fact that seas are rising faster than ever before in human history is enough to facilitate action and adaptation. You also may ask, “What can we do about it?” This question will be addressed in later modules.
For a rapid and fun overview of the history of the Earth’s climate changes, watch the following fascinating monolog video. It summarizes most of the concepts to be discussed in more detail in the materials that follow.
Sea levels change over different spatial and temporal scales. The images produced by altimetry illustrate well the spatial variations, and also provide important data on relatively recent temporal changes. We can examine sea level changes over the short term and long term. Examination of tide gauge data gives us a detailed look at sea level change over a short period of history. These are valuable, but do not show us the whole picture.
If we want to look back at the planet’s ocean levels before people began making measurements, we must use proxy, or indirect measurement. This is the basis of the science of paleoclimatology. Before looking at more information on paleoclimate, we need to understand how these data are obtained.
How do we know what the climate was like 500 million years ago? To reconstruct and understand the fluctuations in climate that have taken place on Earth, scientists use proxy, or indirect data, including data obtained in ice cores, coral, tree rings, and ocean and lake sediment cores.
Paleoclimatologists use various forms of environmental evidence to understand the Earth’s past climate. Earth’s past climate conditions are preserved in tree rings, skeletons of tropical coral reefs, sediment layers in lakes and the ocean, and in the ice of glaciers and ice caps. Using these records, paleoclimatologists can reconstruct climate conditions going back hundreds of millions of years to create graphs such as the one in Figure 4.4 on the previous page.
It was the examination and analysis of ice cores and their trapped molecular contents that revealed the connection between Earth’s atmospheric CO2 and temperature. In order to unlock the information contained in the ice, scientists collect cores and analyze them in slices representing small increments of time, using very precise methods. This way patterns that identify changes in the atmosphere's composition and temperature can be revealed.
For example, the ratio of oxygen isotopes present in the cores ("light" oxygen-16 to "heavy" oxygen-18) can tell the story of global temperatures when the ice formed. Colder temperatures are needed to produce precipitation when water vapor in the atmosphere contains higher levels of oxygen 16.
The paleorecord shows that the Earth’s climate is always changing and that in the distant past (such as the Cretaceous – think end of the dinosaurs’ reign - from 145.5 to 65.5 million years ago), the climate on Earth was much warmer than today and sea levels would have been significantly higher. See Figure 4.4 on the previous page.
The paleoclimate record also shows that in relatively recent geologic time (within the last 2 million years), the Earth underwent a series of glacial periods, which locked much of the Earth’s water in ice which covered the Northern Hemisphere landmasses. This caused the sea level to drop much lower than today (more than 400 ft. below current levels). We are currently in an “interglacial” period during which the Earth has warmed, and the sea level has risen.
Paleoclimate records can also help to shed light on the more recent changes and provide evidence for the anthropomorphic effects on climate and sea level, correlating an unprecedented rapid rise in sea level with increased carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. More on that later.
Please read the article on how scientists use ice cores to reconstruct past climates, "Climate at the core: how scientists study ice cores to reveal Earth’s climate history [4]".
Let’s look at how sea levels have changed over the past 200,000 years of Earth’s history, based on evidence provided by paleoclimatology.
Probably, the factor that influences sea levels on the planet more than any other is the proportion of the Earth’s water that is in the form of ice at any point in time.
The figure below illustrates this very well. Take a look at the curve on the graph, obtained by analyzing oxygen isotopes in ice cores. It represents the fluctuations in sea level from 200,000 years ago to the present (going from right to left on the x-axis). Approximately 125,000 years ago, the sea level was approximately 8 meters higher than it is today. This was during the Sangamonian Interglacial, the last time the north polar ice cap completely melted. After this peak in sea level, ice returned to the planet. And the Wisconsinan Glacial period followed between 80,000 and 20,000 years ago when a glacial maximum, and sea level low stand (more than 130 m lower than today) took place. This is what most people mean when they refer to the "ice age". Glaciers covered much of North America. Following the glacial maximum, we see sea levels rising rapidly - the curve is about as steep as the one leading up to the Sangamonian Interglacial. It began to level off about 5,000 years ago, leading to fairly slow sea level rise in recent geologic time and the sea level human society has been accustomed to.
The figure above (Hearty) illustrates the CO2 fluctuations over 400,000 years and the rapid rise to the recently reached 400 ppm level (Keeling curve). These levels are unprecedented during the past 800,000 years. During the Sangamonian interglacial period mentioned above, at about 130,000 years ago, levels reached 300 ppm, but sea level was much higher than today. A CO2 level of 400 ppm occurred in the Pliocene 3 million years ago, when sea level is estimated to have been 10 to 40 m higher than it is now. The concern is that, based on evidence provided by paleoclimate studies such as those illustrated in the two figures above, this rapid increase in CO2 levels can be correlated with the melting of ice sheets leading to an ice-free planet. This melting is currently being watched closely. If all of Greenland’s ice were to melt, an increase of 5-7 m in sea level would be experienced. This is predicted to lead (as well as flooding of all coastal cities on the globe) to the disruption of the circulation of ocean currents (due to the rapid addition of huge volumes of freshwater to the ocean) that currently dictate the climate patterns as we know them in Earth. Of course, the implications of this scenario are huge. Stay tuned, and pay attention when you hear of news related to this phenomenon.
We will return to the ideas presented in these graphs after considering the complex cause and effect mechanisms that control sea levels on the planet.
Links
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Phanerozoic_Sea_Level.png
[2] https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/
[3] https://www.youtube.com/@SciShow
[4] https://www.climate.gov/news-features/climate-tech/climate-core-how-scientists-study-ice-cores-reveal-earth%E2%80%99s-climate
[5] http://www.eeescience.utoledo.edu/Faculty/Krantz/Va_Coast_figures/Virginia_Coast_figures.htm
[6] http://ecology.com/