EARTH 109
Fundamentals of Shale Energy Development: Geology, Hydraulic Fracturing, and Environmental, Geopolitical and Socio-economic Impacts

Boomtown Impact Model

Boomtown Impact Model

Current research on Marcellus Shale Development draws on important concepts from previous energy development research, including the boomtown impact model. The western United States saw a period of rapid energy development in the 1970s and 1980s. Many coal, oil, and natural gas development projects were located in rural, isolated towns which were unprepared and unaccustomed to the rapid population growth and industrial development taking place. Sociologists, studying these communities, created the boomtown impact model, sometimes called the social disruption hypothesis. The model generally predicts that small communities facing rapid population growth and industrialization will see their services and infrastructure stretched thin, increases in mental health problems, and changes to their quality of life (Jacquet & Kay 2014).

In this section, you will learn about the boom-bust cycle and its impacts, and evaluate whether shale gas development fits within the boomtown impact model.

In the following video, Dr. Brasier describes the Boomtown model and how sociologists study these phenomena.

Video: The Boomtown Effect (1:29)

Click here for video transcript.

Kathy Brasier: So the Boomtown effect is an idea that came out of the 1970s, by a researcher in Gillette Wyoming who is observing what was happening in families in an area where there was rapid development of natural resources. And the idea is that a small community, an isolated rural community, in which the extraction is happening, has a large influx of population that needs to work in that industry, whether they're there because of the specialized technical skills they bring or because they're looking for work in that industry. Population mushrooms, the community doesn't have the capacity to respond to that population growth immediately, there's growing pains. And as a result, families break down, there's domestic violence, there's depression and other mental health issues, substance abuse, crime, sort of all the social ills that are associated with that kind of development was documented in early development. That boomtown model is what we have started with when it came to shale development. So just trying to understand what happens when you have rapid growth in a community, particularly rural communities, we're here in the Marcellus, we've seen more of that kind of development. And trying to understand how communities adapt, are affected, and how families in particular, and individuals, are affected by that development.


Check Your Understanding


Required Reading

Read: Residents' Perceptions of Community and Environmental Impacts from Development of Natural Gas in the Marcellus Shale: A Comparison of Pennsylvania and New York Cases

This reading outlines the perceptions of impacts from community members over time and across space using qualitative data from interviews. As you read the article, complete Activity 2.

Activity 2

Divide a piece of paper into three sections and label each section with Boom Stage, Bust Stage, and Recovery Stage. As you read the “Background” section (pages 34-38), fill in each section with corresponding characteristics from the literature. Once you are done, check your answers against the ones given below. Check to see if your responses identify or give consideration to the characteristics of each stage of development. (Some characteristics don’t fit neatly within one stage or the other.)